The role of identity development, future time perspective and career maturity in first-year students' academic success

[摘要] English: The retention of first-year students and poor throughput rates are problems plaguing higher education globally and South Africa in particular. A significant number of students drop out of university in their first year of study and those who ultimately graduate take longer periods to complete their undergraduate degree. Many first-year students who gain access to higher education are reported to be under-prepared and ill equipped to meet the expectation and the assumption that they should be academically and developmentally prepared to handle the responsibilities associated with higher learning and its unique challenges. First-year students are developmentally at the emerging adulthood stage, where they are generally engaged in a process directed towards their future roles and career aspirations. It was therefore necessary to consider theoretical underpinnings of identity and career development as significant factors at play in students' intrapsychic preparedness and psychological resilience for the task at hand. These two developmental trajectories are significantly influenced by one's time orientation, specifically one's future time perspective. The main aim of this study was to investigate the role of career maturity and future time perspective in the relationship between identity development and the academic success of first-year students at university. Thus, the study firstly aimed to determine whether identity development could significantly predict the academic success of first-year students at university and secondly, it investigated the mediating and moderating roles of both career maturity and future time perspective. This investigation was extended to include gender and race/ethnicity as factors influencing the outcome. From the moderated hierarchical multiple regression analyses conducted to investigate the possible effect of gender and race/ethnicity on the relationship between identity development and academic success, it became clear that gender did not moderate this relationship whereas race/ethnicity succeeded in moderating the relationship. Calculated correlation coefficients between the relevant variables indicated that only the commitment scale correlated significantly (at the 5% level) with academic success for the total group and the white students. None of the identity styles reflected a significant relationship with academic success for the black learners. An increased number of career maturity variables appeared to be significantly related to academic success for the total group and for the black and white students. Future time perspective appeared to be significantly related to academic success for the total group as well as for the black and white students. None of the identity styles succeeded in predicting a significant percentage of variance in both the black and white students' academic success. Therefore, the role of identity development in predicting academic success remains inconclusive and calls for further exploration. The following career maturity scales moderated the relationship between the normative identity and academic success: decision making moderated this relationship for the black students; career information moderated this relationship for both the black and the white students; and, lastly, integration of self- and career information moderated this relationship for the white students. Career information, integration of self- and career information as well as career planning moderated the relationship between diffuse-avoidant style and academic success for the white students. Lastly, future time perspective moderated the relationship between identity commitment and academic success for the black first-year students and not for the white students. This appears to be a strange finding as white students are expected to be more future-oriented and goal directed in that these are the associated effects of identity exploration and the development of identity commitments over time; processes that are often associated with Western cultural values.

[发布机构] University of the Free State