A certain idea of reality : possible worlds in the films of Michael Winterbottom

[摘要] ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This dissertation investigates the notion of realism and in particular its applicability to the visual and narrative strategies employed in eight of Michael Winterbottom's films. Realism is a term that has strong ties to the reality of the viewer, but this reality that governs the conventions for making a judgment on a work's realism is in constant flux. Likewise, on the side of the film's production, any number of tactics may be deployed to increase the viewer's sense of realism and the research undertaken here looks at a variety of approaches to the creation and assessment of realism in a film.Many of the films discussed here are depictions of past events and the tension between the realistic reconstruction of the past and the necessary artifice that is inherent in such representations are studied in the light of the theories of possible and fictional worlds. Possible worlds are constituted by states of affairs that would be possible in the actual world; in the same way, realistic representations reflect the possibilities of the actual world without necessarily being an identical copy of reality. David Lewis's concept of counterparts plays an important role in the analysis of filmic components, especially when these components are representations of actual entities. In addition to a consideration of counterparts, this dissertation will also look at the role of the 'fictional operator which facilitates discussion about fictional truths.While the fictional operator creates counterparts of actually existing entities and films remain always already fictional, the actual world retains an important role in fiction. In postmodern cinema the viewer is encouraged to use knowledge obtained from other worlds – either actual or imaginary – so as to enhance appreciation (analytical as much as emotional) of the film even more. The concept of realism has been thoroughly problematised, but many strategies continue to connect the events of the fiction either with the 'real world or with other worlds that rival the importance of the 'real world.It is suggested that the so-called 'real world used to measure realism can refer to any world outside the realm of the particular fiction. Realism can be a product of a visualstyle as well as the particular development of a narrative and in both cases the viewer measures the conditions against her own experience of other worlds. The world of the film is a fictional reality that is sometimes a representation of the actual world, but the relationship between the two worlds can never be completely transparent, in spite of the efforts that many filmmakers have made in this respect.

[发布机构] Stellenbosch University