White women writing the (post)colony : creolite, home and estrangement in novels by Rhys, Duras and Van Niekerk

[摘要] ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This thesis investigates the ways in which white subjectivity is shaped by colonial and imperial spaces. Jean Rhys's Voyage in the Dark (1934), Marguerite Duras's The Sea Wall (1952/1967) and Marlene van Niekerk's Agaat (2004/2006) are vastly different novels from multifarious literary traditions, yet they join each other through their protagonists: white creole women. In this study, I engage most prominently with white creole female subjectivity, framing my study with theories of the subject proposed by Homi Bhabha and Judith Butler. In order to interrogate creolité, I draw on Bhabha's concept of 'thirdness – a category signifying a position in-between binary categories of representation – and Butler's conceptualisation of subjectivity/subjection, through which she highlights the ambivalences of the process of interpellation. I also read through lenses proposed by whiteness studies in the United States and South Africa, approaching creolité not as an indication of racial hybridity, but rather a term connoting cultural and political in-betweenness. As my discussions of the novels illustrate, white creole femininity in the (post)colony is a subject position through which intricate webs of 'complicity and resistance (Whitlock 349) have to be negotiated. Looking at the white creole women as textual constructs embedded in genres which advance a particular set of politics, I explore the ways in which the authors, through their novels and protagonists, navigate various political and cultural ambiguities and inconsistencies.Establishing the theoretical framework in the introductory first chapter, in Chapter 2 I read Rhys's novel as a modernist text that elicits a particular postcolonial politics. I link the protagonist's social alienation in London and the Caribbean to the experience of the middle passage; this is followed by an exploration of her sexuality with reference to the figures of the European prostitute and the 'Hottentot' Venus. In Chapter 3 I investigate Duras's novel and trace the ways in which a family of impoverished 'Colonial natives (Duras 138) continually fail to establish themselves as 'legitimate' white colonials in (French colonial) Southeast Asia. Lastly, in Chapter 4, I approach Van Niekerk's novel not only as a feminist re-writing of the plaasroman, but also as a 'complicitous critique (Warnes 121) that reflects nostalgically – yet critically – on Afrikaner nationalism. I show how the novel registers a vision of the quotidian that is uncomfortable and unhomely.Together, the three novels speak in highly comparable and complex ways about how white creole women experience (un)homeliness in the (post)colony. This thesis probes the extent to which the novels negotiate 'home' (or the lack thereof): displaced, alienated and often expressing forms of nostalgia, the protagonists struggle to establish forms of belonging in spaces within which they oscillate between opposed cultures, ideologies and politics. Ultimately, my study is crucially underscored by the question of displacement and estrangement (in various guises), and the way in which they inflect the establishment and performance of femininity.

[发布机构] Stellenbosch University